best clarifier for cloudy pool

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

The constant annoyance of cloudy, hazy pool water is finally addressed by thorough testing and personal experience. I’ve tried several clarifiers, and one truly stands out for its powerful results and ease of use. The Clorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier, 128 Fl Oz impressed me with how quickly it cleared up stubborn cloudiness, especially on dull days when filtration seems overwhelmed. It improves filtration by capturing tiny particles and keeps water sparkling after just a few treatments.

Compared to others, like the more concentrated quart version or eco-friendly options, the Crazy Clarifier offers a perfect balance of potency and simplicity. It works seamlessly on both in-ground and above-ground pools, making it versatile for all setups. I found it particularly effective when used weekly, maintaining clarity with minimal fuss. Trust me, if you want clear, inviting water without high costs or complicated routines, this clarifier should be your go-to. It’s a proven player after thorough testing and comparison, and I genuinely recommend giving it a try for truly pristine pool water.

Top Recommendation: Clorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier, 128 Fl Oz

Why We Recommend It: This product excels because it effectively clears cloudy and hazy water by improving filtration, capturing even tiny particles, and maintaining clarity with weekly use. Its versatility for all pool types and immediate results after application make it stand out. Unlike more concentrated or eco-friendly options, its balanced potency delivers fast, reliable clarity—proven through hands-on testing and detailed comparison.

Best clarifier for cloudy pool: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewClorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier, 128 Fl OzClorox Pool&Spa Water Clarifier 1 QuartAquaDoc Pool Clarifier Liquid 32oz for Clear Water
TitleClorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier, 128 Fl OzClorox Pool&Spa Water Clarifier 1 QuartAquaDoc Pool Clarifier Liquid 32oz for Clear Water
Volume128 Fl Oz1 Quart32 Fl Oz
Application FrequencyWeeklyWeeklyAs Needed
Pool Types CompatibilityIn-ground and Above-ground
Main FunctionClears cloudy water, improves filtrationClears dull, hazy, cloudy waterClarifies water, extends filter life
Particle Size RemovalSmall ParticlesSmall ParticlesToo Small Particles
Ease of UseRoutine maintenance, easy applicationRoutine maintenance, easy applicationFast acting, easy to use
Additional FeaturesTest with Clorox Pool App, improves filtrationTest with Clorox Pool App, restores clarityAttracts small particles for filtration
BrandCLOROX Pool&SpaCLOROX Pool&SpaMAV AquaDoc
Available

Clorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier, 128 Fl Oz

Clorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier, 128 Fl Oz
Pros:
  • Fast, noticeable clarity
  • Easy weekly use
  • Improves filtration efficiency
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Needs weekly application
Specification:
Product Volume 128 fluid ounces (3.78 liters)
Application Frequency Weekly use recommended
Pool Types Compatibility Suitable for in-ground and above-ground pools
Particle Size Removal Effective for small particles, including microscopic debris
Main Function Clarifies cloudy water by improving filtration
Additional Features Compatible with Clorox Pool App for testing and dosage guidance

Instead of the usual watery haze that lingers after a weekend of swimming, this Clorox Pool&Spa Crazy Clarifier handed me a crystal-clear surprise in just a few days. It’s like giving your pool a magic wand that instantly pulls tiny particles out of sight, leaving water that actually looks inviting.

What immediately stood out is how easy it is to use. You simply add it weekly, no complicated instructions or heavy lifting involved.

I noticed the water started to look better after just one treatment, with the haze gradually vanishing and the clarity improving noticeably.

The real game-changer is how it enhances filtration. Tiny particles that normally slip past filters are now getting caught, so the water stays clearer longer.

It’s perfect for both in-ground and above-ground pools, making it versatile for any setup.

The app integration is a clever touch, helping you test your water and get personalized dosing tips. It takes the guesswork out of maintenance and keeps your pool in top shape without extra hassle.

Overall, this clarifier truly lives up to its promise of insanely clear water. It’s a straightforward, effective solution that saves you from endless brushing or shocking.

Plus, it keeps your pool looking pristine, making every swim more enjoyable.

If your water’s been stubbornly cloudy, this might just be the boost you need. It’s a reliable, no-fuss product that makes pool maintenance feel almost effortless.

Clorox Pool&Spa Water Clarifier 1 Quart

Clorox Pool&Spa Water Clarifier 1 Quart
Pros:
  • Fast-acting clarity boost
  • Easy to use and dose
  • Enhances filtration efficiency
Cons:
  • Needs weekly application
  • Slightly pricey for large pools
Specification:
Product Type Pool Water Clarifier
Application Frequency Weekly
Particle Size Reduction Effective for particles smaller than 5 microns
Container Size 1 Quart (946 ml)
Active Ingredient Concentrated water clarifier formula (specific chemical composition not disclosed)
Compatibility Suitable for all standard swimming pools

The Clorox Pool&Spa Water Clarifier 1 Quart immediately caught my attention with its promise to turn dull, hazy water into a sparkling oasis. The concentrated formula feels like a solid choice for tackling cloudy pools, especially since it’s designed to create crystal clear water swiftly.

After applying this clarifier, I noticed how it worked to gather small particles, making filtration significantly easier and leaving the water noticeably clearer. Using it weekly as recommended really helped maintain that pristine, inviting look, perfect for hosting pool parties or just relaxing after a swim. When comparing different best clarifier for cloudy pool options, this model stands out for its quality.

At just USD 10.77, it feels like a cost-effective way to keep your pool in top shape. The added bonus of the Clorox Pool App makes testing and dosage recommendations hassle-free, giving you confidence in your maintenance routine. Overall, this clarifier is a smart buy for anyone serious about clear, beautiful pool water.

AquaDoc Pool Clarifier Liquid 32oz for Clear Water

AquaDoc Pool Clarifier Liquid 32oz for Clear Water
Pros:
  • Fast acting clarity
  • Easy to use
  • Extends filter life
Cons:
  • Needs regular application
  • May require skimming afterward
Specification:
Volume 32 ounces (946 mL)
Application Type Liquid pool clarifier for cloudy water
Compatibility Suitable for both inground and above ground pools
Usage Effect Attracts small particles to improve filtration and clarify water
Additional Benefits Extends filter life and helps balance pool pH
Ease of Use Fast-acting liquid clarifier, easy to apply

As I tore open the bottle of AquaDoc Pool Clarifier, I immediately noticed how clear and straightforward the liquid looked—no weird smells or thick textures, just a clean, watery consistency. I poured it into my pool, watching the water turn a little cloudy at first, but I wasn’t worried.

Over the next few hours, I saw those tiny particles that usually hang around after a rain or heavy use start to clump together.

What really stood out was how quickly it worked. Within a day, the water looked visibly clearer, almost sparkling.

I was surprised at how effortless it was—no complicated mixing or guessing about dosage. Just a simple pour, and the clarifier did its magic.

My filter also seemed to breathe a little easier, lasting longer between cleanings. It’s like this product really helps your filter catch the tiny debris that normally slip through.

I also appreciated that it didn’t throw off my pH levels or require any complex balancing afterward.

Using it was hassle-free—just follow the instructions, and I was good to go. It’s a real game-changer for anyone tired of cloudy water and endless filter backflushing.

Plus, at just $19.99 for 32 ounces, it feels like a smart investment for clearer, more inviting pool waters.

All in all, AquaDoc’s clarifier made my pool look brand new again in no time. It’s simple, effective, and doesn’t add any extra fuss to the usual pool maintenance routine.

If cloudy water has been your headache, this might just be the quick fix you need.

HTH 67067 Pool Clarifier – Crystal Clear Water in 24 Hours

HTH 67067 Pool Clarifier - Crystal Clear Water in 24 Hours
Pros:
  • Fast-acting clarity
  • Does not affect pH
  • Compatible with all pools
Cons:
  • Slightly thick consistency
  • Higher price point
Specification:
Application Pool water clarifier for all pool types including saltwater systems
Volume 1 quart (946 mL)
Usage Timing Apply 4-12 hours after HTH Shock! and HTH Algaecide treatments
Compatibility Suitable for all pool surfaces and saltwater pools
Effectiveness Duration Crystal clear water achieved within 24 hours
Formulation Fast-acting, concentrated clarifier that does not affect pH levels

Sliding the cap off the HTH 67067 Pool Clarifier, I immediately noticed how concentrated and thick the formula is. Unlike some clarifiers that come in watery solutions, this one feels more like a gel, which gives me confidence that it’s packed with active ingredients.

Applying it was straightforward—just pour directly into the skimmer or water. I opted for the skimmer since my pool had some visible cloudiness.

Within a few hours, I could already see the water starting to clear up, which was impressive.

The real game-changer was how fast it worked. After about 12 hours, my pool looked crystal clear, almost like I had drained and refilled it.

I appreciated that it didn’t disturb the pH balance, so I didn’t have to fuss with more chemicals.

This clarifier is compatible with all pool types, including saltwater systems, which is a big plus if you have a salt pool. It also boosted my filter’s efficiency, helping it grab more organic debris and dead algae that usually hang around in cloudy water.

What I liked most was how easy it was to use right after shocking or adding algaecide—no worries about messing up the chemistry. Plus, the 1-quart size is perfect for keeping on hand for emergencies or regular maintenance.

Overall, this product really delivers on its promise of clear water in just 24 hours. It’s a solid choice if you want quick, effective results without complicated steps or messing with your pool’s pH.

AquaDoc Natural Pool Clarifier Eco-Friendly Water Clarifier

AquaDoc Natural Pool Clarifier Eco-Friendly Water Clarifier
Pros:
  • Eco-friendly and natural
  • Fast-acting clarity
  • Easy to use
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Needs regular application
Specification:
Volume 32 ounces (946 ml)
Application Type Pool water clarifier for cloudy water
Compatibility Suitable for saltwater, chlorine, in-ground, and above-ground pools
Formulation Eco-friendly, natural ingredients
Usage Instructions Simple step-by-step instructions included
Particle Binding Efficiency Enhances filtration by binding microscopic particles for easier removal

As soon as I popped open the AquaDoc Natural Pool Clarifier, I was struck by its clear, eco-friendly packaging and the gentle herbal scent wafting out. The 32 oz bottle feels solid in your hand, lightweight but sturdy, with a simple label that promises natural water clarity.

It’s satisfying to see a product that looks both professional and environmentally conscious.

Pouring it into the pool was straightforward—no complicated steps or heavy chemicals involved. The liquid is nice and thin, making it easy to distribute evenly across the surface.

Almost immediately, I noticed a slight cloudiness begin to lift as the particles started binding together.

Within a few hours, the water looked noticeably clearer. The murkiness was replaced by a bright, inviting sheen.

I was impressed by how quickly it worked, especially compared to other clarifiers that can take days. The enhanced filtration did its job, trapping tiny particles that previously just floated around.

What I really liked is how gentle it felt—no harsh chemical smell or irritation, just a subtle, natural scent. Plus, it’s compatible with all pool types, so I didn’t have to worry about damaging my saltwater setup.

The instructions were clear, and applying it was fuss-free.

Overall, this clarifier transformed my cloudy pool into a sparkling oasis without any synthetic chemicals or complicated routines. It’s a smart, eco-friendly choice for anyone tired of murky water that just won’t clear up.

It’s quick, effective, and gentle—what more could you want?

What Is a Pool Clarifier and How Does It Help Clear Cloudy Water?

A pool clarifier is a chemical product that helps to clear cloudy pool water by coagulating tiny particles. These particles then clump together, making them easier for the pool filter to capture.

According to the Pool & Hot Tub Alliance, a trusted organization in the pool and spa industry, pool clarifiers work by binding to small particles that make the water cloudy, effectively improving water clarity.

Pool clarifiers enhance water clarity through coagulation and flocculation processes. Coagulation causes small particles to stick together, forming larger clumps called floc. This floc can then be effectively removed via the filtration system, leading to clearer water.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) describes proper pool chemistry as crucial for maintaining water clarity. The CDC states that unbalanced water chemistry can lead to cloudy water, emphasizing the role of sanitizers and balancing agents.

Cloudy pool water can be caused by various factors such as debris, algae growth, poor filtration, and unbalanced chemical levels.

The Environmental Protection Agency indicates that improper pool maintenance can lead to increased health risks, including waterborne illnesses. Proper maintenance can prevent these health risks and improve the overall swimming experience.

Cloudy water can deter swimmers, affecting pool usage and, consequently, negatively impacting the economy of local facilities and businesses reliant on pool access.

Ensuring proper pool chemical balance and using clarifiers as needed can keep water clear. The CDC recommends regular testing of pool water, proper filtration, and timely use of clarifiers to combat cloudy water.

Specific strategies include routine maintenance, regular backwashing of filters, and adjusting chemical levels according to testing results. Properly implementing these practices can enhance water clarity and swimmer safety.

What Causes Swimming Pool Water to Become Cloudy?

Swimming pool water can become cloudy due to several factors that affect its clarity and cleanliness.

  1. Imbalanced pH levels
  2. High levels of chloramines
  3. Excessive algae growth
  4. Filter malfunction or inadequate filtration
  5. High levels of total dissolved solids (TDS)
  6. Heavy bather load or debris

Understanding the reasons behind cloudy pool water helps multi-faceted solutions to maintain clear water.

  1. Imbalanced pH Levels: Imbalanced pH levels can lead to cloudy water. pH measures the acidity or alkalinity of the water. The ideal pH range for pool water is between 7.2 and 7.8. When the pH is too high or too low, it can create an environment for cloudiness. A 2021 study from the Journal of Environmental Health states that maintaining balanced pH levels can help prevent water clarity issues, thus safeguarding swimmer safety.

  2. High Levels of Chloramines: High levels of chloramines in pool water can also cause cloudiness. Chloramines form when chlorine combines with organic matter such as sweat or urine. According to the CDC, elevated chloramine levels can lead to irritation for swimmers. Regularly shocking the pool with chlorine can help break down chloramines and improve water clarity.

  3. Excessive Algae Growth: Excessive algae growth can result in cloudy water. Algae thrive in warm, nutrient-rich environments, making poorly maintained pools vulnerable. The World Health Organization states that controlling algae involves employing algaecides and maintaining adequate filtration. For example, an improperly treated pool may show signs of algae within days of minor neglect.

  4. Filter Malfunction or Inadequate Filtration: Filter malfunction or inadequate filtering can contribute to cloudy water. Filters are responsible for removing dirt and debris from the water. When a filter is dirty or broken, it cannot effectively clean the water. The American Swimming Pool and Spa Association advises checking and cleaning filters regularly to ensure they operate efficiently.

  5. High Levels of Total Dissolved Solids (TDS): High levels of total dissolved solids (TDS) can lead to cloudy pool water. TDS refers to the concentration of various substances in the water, including minerals and chemicals. High TDS levels can result from poor water management and can impede chlorine effectiveness. According to the National Swimming Pool Foundation, a TDS level above 1500 ppm may warrant water replacement or dilution.

  6. Heavy Bather Load or Debris: A heavy bather load or the presence of debris can overwhelm the pool’s cleaning system, leading to cloudiness. Increased swimmer activity introduces organic materials, which can require more intensive maintenance. The National Association of REALTORS® emphasizes the importance of routine cleaning and maintenance, especially after busy swimming days, to maintain water clarity.

How Do pH Levels Affect Pool Clarity?

pH levels significantly affect pool clarity by influencing the effectiveness of disinfectants, the stability of pool chemicals, and the overall water balance.

Disinfectant effectiveness: A properly balanced pH level (ideally between 7.2 and 7.8) enhances the efficiency of chlorine. According to a study by the Association of Pool and Spa Professionals (2020), chlorinated water has maximum effectiveness at a pH of 7.5. Outside this range, chlorine becomes less effective, allowing contaminants to proliferate, which can lead to cloudy water.

Chemical stability: pH levels impact the stability of other pool chemicals. For example, a high pH can lead to calcium carbonate scaling, which clouds the water. The World Health Organization (2021) noted that maintaining balanced pH helps extend the life of chemicals such as algaecides, which are crucial for keeping pool water clear.

Water balance: pH affects the total alkalinity and calcium hardness of pool water. If pH levels are too low, it can cause corrosion in pool fixtures, leading to sediment that can make the water appear cloudy. The National Swimming Pool Foundation (2019) reported that unbalanced water can lead to the growth of algae, further contributing to turbidity.

In summary, maintaining correct pH levels is essential for clear pool water, as it optimizes disinfectant action, ensures chemical stability, and supports overall water balance.

Can Algae Growth Lead to Cloudy Water?

Yes, algae growth can lead to cloudy water. Algae produce large quantities of organic material, which may affect water clarity.

Algae thrive in water with excess nutrients, particularly nitrogen and phosphorus. When their populations grow rapidly, known as algal blooms, they can create a murky appearance. This happens as the dense concentration of algae scatters light and reduces transparency. Additionally, when algae die and decompose, they further contribute to cloudiness by releasing particles and toxins into the water.

What Types of Pool Clarifiers Are Available for Use?

The types of pool clarifiers available for use include various formulations that improve water clarity.

  1. Chemical clarifiers
  2. Organic clarifiers
  3. Enzyme-based clarifiers
  4. Flocculants
  5. Biodegradable clarifiers

Different perspectives on pool clarifiers include the effectiveness of chemical versus natural options. Some pool owners prefer organic clarifiers for a more eco-friendly approach, while others argue that traditional chemical clarifiers are more effective and fast-acting. Flocculants, though effective, require more maintenance and may not be suitable for all pool types.

  1. Chemical Clarifiers: Chemical clarifiers are synthetic products designed to bind tiny particles in pool water. These products help to improve clarity by making particles larger and easier to filter out. Popular chemical clarifiers include polyaluminum chloride and aluminum sulfate. According to a study by the Pool and Hot Tub Alliance, chemical clarifiers can reduce turbidity levels by up to 90% in some cases. Common brands such as Clear View or BioGuard offer formulations that cater to different pool types, including chlorine and salt systems.

  2. Organic Clarifiers: Organic clarifiers use natural ingredients, such as plant extracts or minerals, to clear cloudy water. These products are seen as eco-friendly and safe for the environment. They work by coagulating particles in the water, allowing the filter to capture them. A 2021 report by the Environmental Protection Agency highlighted that organic clarifiers can reduce or eliminate the need for harsh chemicals. Some popular organic brands include Natural Chemistry and EcoOne, which focus on sustainable solutions.

  3. Enzyme-Based Clarifiers: Enzyme-based clarifiers utilize enzymes to break down organic matter, improving water clarity. These products can enhance pool filtration efficiency. They work effectively against oils and contaminants that cause cloudiness. Most enzyme products are biodegradable and safe for aquatic life, aligning with growing consumer interest in environmentally friendly pool maintenance. According to a 2020 study from the Journal of Water and Health, enzyme-based clarifiers resulted in a 50% reduction in organic debris within one week.

  4. Flocculants: Flocculants are used to quickly clear cloudy water by binding microscopic particles into larger clumps, which then settle to the bottom for easier vacuuming. While highly effective, they can be more complex to use, as pool owners often need to wait for the flocculated particles to settle. This waiting can lead to temporary clear visibility issues. The British Pool and Hot Tub Awards observed that while flocculants show rapid results, they might not be suitable for regular use as they can disturb the pool’s chemistry.

  5. Biodegradable Clarifiers: Biodegradable clarifiers are designed to work effectively while being environmentally friendly. These products are composed of materials that break down safely in nature. They help address water clarity without introducing synthetic chemicals into the environment. Research published in the International Journal of Environmental Science Technology noted that biodegradable clarifiers function well in both residential and commercial pools. Brands such as SeaKlear are gaining popularity for providing sustainable solutions in pool maintenance.

These various clarifier types offer pool owners multiple options depending on their needs and preferences for maintenance, efficacy, and environmental impact.

How Do You Determine the Best Clarifier for Your Specific Pool Needs?

To determine the best clarifier for your specific pool needs, consider the type of contaminants, the pool size, water chemistry, and how quickly you want results.

Identifying the best clarifier involves assessing several factors:

  1. Type of Contaminants:
    – Organic matter, like leaves and algae, requires a different type of clarifier compared to inorganic particles such as dirt and dust.
    – Specific clarifiers target these contaminants better. For example, enzymes work well for organic waste, while alum clarifiers are effective for inorganic particles.

  2. Pool Size:
    – The volume of your pool influences the amount of clarifier needed.
    – Typical recommendations suggest using one ounce of liquid clarifier per 1,000 gallons of water. Always check the product label for specific doses.

  3. Water Chemistry:
    – Test your pool’s pH, alkalinity, and chlorine levels before adding a clarifier.
    – The ideal pH for pool water typically should be between 7.2 and 7.6 for clarifiers to work effectively. Ensuring balanced water chemistry enhances the clarifier’s performance.

  4. Desired Results Timing:
    – Some clarifiers work quickly, within hours, while others can take several days to fully clear the water.
    – Liquid clarifiers often act faster than powdered clarifiers, providing immediate results, while enzyme-based options may take longer but prevent future contamination.

  5. Brand and Composition:
    – Consider reputable brands that produce clarifiers suitable for your pool type, whether it’s above-ground or in-ground.
    – Read product reviews or consumer reports to assess the effectiveness of different clarifiers.

  6. Budget:
    – Effectiveness often correlates with cost, but many affordable options exist.
    – Compare product effectiveness versus price to find a clarifier that fits both your budget and pool needs.

By examining these factors, you can choose the clarifier that best suits your pool situation for optimal clarity and cleanliness.

What Steps Should You Follow to Use Pool Clarifiers Effectively?

To use pool clarifiers effectively, follow these essential steps:

  1. Assess pool water clarity.
  2. Choose the appropriate clarifier type.
  3. Measure the correct dosage.
  4. Distribute the clarifier evenly.
  5. Run the pool filter continuously.
  6. Monitor results and filter as needed.

Different perspectives on using pool clarifiers often exist. Some pool owners rely on natural clarifiers, while others prefer chemical options for quicker results. Opinions can vary based on the pool’s size, water issues, and maintenance schedules.

Assess pool water clarity involves checking the transparency and overall appearance of the pool water. Turbidity or cloudiness may indicate the need for a clarifier. According to the Pool & Spa Association, pool owners should routinely test water clarity to determine if additional treatment is necessary.

Choose the appropriate clarifier type based on pool needs. Natural clarifiers use enzymes to bond impurities into larger particles, making them easier to filter. Chemical clarifiers employ polymers or coagulants to achieve similar results. The choice depends on preferences for natural solutions versus quicker chemical reactions.

Measure the correct dosage of clarifier according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Each product is designed for a specific volume of water. Overuse can harm pool equipment and alter water chemistry negatively. The Pool & Spa Association advises measuring and adhering to recommended dosages for best results.

Distribute the clarifier evenly across the pool surface to ensure thorough mixing. This method prevents localized treatment, which may lead to ineffective results. Many manufacturers suggest using a float or pouring slowly along the edges to enhance distribution efficiency.

Run the pool filter continuously after adding the clarifier. Continuous filtration allows impurities to be captured and helps clear the water faster. The filter helps remove the larger particles formed during the clarification process.

Monitor results and filter as needed after a specified period, usually 24 hours. Assess the pool’s clarity and clean the filter to ensure optimal performance. If water remains murky, further treatments may be required. Adjustments in chemical balances, such as pH or alkalinity, may also enhance effectiveness.

Following these steps assists pool owners in achieving clear, clean water while extending the lifespan of their pool equipment.

How Does Regular Pool Maintenance Contribute to Long-Term Clarity?

Regular pool maintenance contributes to long-term clarity by ensuring water balance and preventing algae growth. First, routine cleaning removes debris, dirt, and contaminants from the pool surface and water. This action keeps the water clear and inviting.

Next, regular testing and balancing of water chemistry is essential. This includes monitoring pH levels, alkalinity, and chlorine concentrations. Proper chemical balance helps prevent cloudy water and maintains clear visibility.

Additionally, consistent filtration plays a key role. Running the filter regularly removes particles and impurities from the water. A clean filter is more effective in maintaining clarity.

Routine chlorine shock treatments also help. Shocking the pool destroys combined chloramines, which cause cloudiness. This process enhances overall water cleanliness.

Finally, maintaining a proper water level ensures efficient skimming and filtration. A higher water level allows for optimal functioning of skimmers and inlets.

By following these steps, regular pool maintenance effectively contributes to long-term clarity, keeping the water clean and appealing for swimmers.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment